Welcome to The Pickled Goat
Located in the heart of New Baltimore, The Pickled Goat offers a relaxed setting with handcrafted American classics, local brews, and friendly service. Whether you're here for lunch, dinner, or just a drink with good company, you'll find a comfortable place to unwind and enjoy the moment.
Wings that Soar - Taste the Difference
We buy the best chicken money can buy, and it shows in every bite. No doubt about it - our wings are the real deal. Crispy, saucy and packed with bold flavors that will keep the locals coming back for more.
Once you try them, nothing else compares
Burgers That Mean Business
At The Local Goat, we don’t just flip patties — we craft burgers worth talking about. Sure, we’ve got the classics, but our real flavor flex? Signature creations like the sweet and savory Peanut Butter & Jelly Burger and the bold, one-of-a-kind Goat Burger with marinated goat cheese.
Juicy, imaginative, and grilled to perfection — these aren’t just burgers.
They’re a whole experience.This is burger heaven.
Don't Believe our Words But Believe your Eyes
Big Drinks. Bigger Vibes
Dive into our outrageous fish bowls, wild nights, and the unforgettable moments that make The Pickled Goat one of a kind.
New Baltimore's Favorite Spot
Check What’s Cookin’
Got Plans Yet?
Planning a night out, a laid-back lunch, or something in between? Reserve your table at The Pickled Goat and skip the wait. With bold flavors, good drinks, and a warm, easygoing vibe, it’s the kind of place worth locking in. Click below and we’ll have your spot ready.
Get Your Game On
A world of excitement at our Arcade Room! Located at The Pickled Goat, this space is packed with classic games, great food, and a lively atmosphere. Whether you’re a gamer or just looking for a fun outing, our arcade offers something for everyone. Come challenge your friends, enjoy delicious bites, and make some unforgettable memories!
A Spot for Everyone
Bring the whole crew—there’s something here for all. Relax on the patio, sip on a well-crafted drink, or let the little ones pick from their own menu. From date nights to family dinners, The Pickled Goat keeps it easy, fun, and full of flavor.
Swing By and Stay a While
We’re here when you’re hungry, thirsty, or just in the mood for good company. Stop in, grab a seat, and enjoy the vibe—indoors or out.
Our Hours:
Tuesday–Thursday: 11 AM–10 PM
Friday–Saturday: 11 AM–12 AM
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
Closed Mondays
What our guests are saying
Nice small town business. Glad they are in my Neighborhood. Does not have a huge amount of seating but enough to bring some friends for the night crowd. Plenty of Alcohol and seating outside.
Chris M.
Excellent service, thank you, Kristin. food is made with love. Great menus, lunch specials. Best slim I've ever had! Wings looked great , fries and tots too.
Nicole F.
This was a super fun and great first experience. We met some friends who hadn't been there either, and we got a table right away. The place was really busy but our waitress was very attentive and pleasant.
Joe T.
Featuring
Has Outdoor Seating
Serves Great Cocktails
Has Kids' Menu
The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!